Toilet Repair and Replacement in the Tri-Valley

Trusted Local Plumbers Backed by 2,300+ Five-Star Reviews

A toilet that runs all night, clogs every week or leaks at the base wastes water and can damage the floor. Barnett Plumbing & Water Heaters repairs and replaces toilets across Livermore, Pleasanton, Dublin, San Ramon and the rest of the Tri-Valley. We find the cause first, then tell you plainly whether a repair makes sense or a new toilet is the better call. Same-day visits, and a fixed-rate price before we start.

CA Contractor License #910529 (C-36 Plumbing)
Get Help Today
Fast Response. No Obligation.
Message and data rates may apply. Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions

2,300+ five-star reviews

Same-day service

3-hour arrival windows

Fixed-rate price up front

Signs You Need Toilet Repair

Toilets are simple machines, and most problems give a clear sign. If you notice any of these, it is time to have it looked at.

Keeps running

Water runs after the flush, or the tank refills on its own.

Weak or double flush

The bowl does not clear the first time.

Water at the base

A puddle or damp floor around the toilet.

Clogs again and again

It clogs more than once a month.

Rocks or wobbles

The toilet moves when you sit down.

Gurgling

Bubbling in the bowl when other fixtures drain.

Slow to refill

The tank takes a long time to fill after a flush.

Sewer smell

An odor at the base of the toilet.

Toilet overflowing? Turn the valve behind the toilet clockwise to shut off the water, and do not flush again. Then call us.

Toilet Repairs We Do Most

Our plumber checks the whole toilet, not just the part that failed, and gives you a fixed-rate price before any work starts.

Fill valve

A worn fill valve makes the toilet run, hiss or refill slowly.

Flapper and flush valve

A flapper that no longer seals lets water leak from the tank into the bowl.

Wax ring

A failed wax ring lets water and sewer odor out at the base.

Toilet flange

A cracked or loose flange lets the toilet rock and leak.

Supply line and shut-off valve

We replace worn supply lines and valves before they burst or seize.

Tank-to-bowl leaks

New bolts and gaskets stop leaks between the tank and the bowl.

Clogs

We clear the toilet and check whether the clog is in the toilet or farther down the line.

Toilet replacement

We remove the old toilet, set the new one on a new wax ring and test it.

When we replace a toilet, we take the old one away.

Repair or Replace?

Most toilets can be repaired. These are the cases where we suggest one or the other.

Usually worth repairing

  • A running toilet from a worn flapper or fill valve
  • A leak at the supply line or shut-off valve
  • A failed wax ring
  • A single clog

Usually time to replace

  • A cracked tank or bowl
  • A toilet that clogs over and over
  • Repairs that keep adding up
  • An older toilet that uses far more water per flush

From Our Toilet Jobs

Real photos from Tri-Valley homes.

Old toilet flange and wax ring with the toilet removed

Under the toilet. The old flange and wax ring with the toilet pulled.

Fill valve and flush valve inside a toilet tank

Inside the tank. The fill valve and flush valve inside a toilet tank.

New toilet installed in a Dublin bathroom

New toilet. A new toilet installed in a Dublin bathroom.

Toilets We Install

One-piece and two-piece

Two-piece toilets are the most common and the simplest to service. One-piece toilets have no seam between the tank and bowl, so they are easier to clean.

High-efficiency

Newer toilets use much less water per flush than older ones and still clear the bowl.

Comfort height

A taller seat, about chair height, that is easier to sit down on and stand up from.

How a Toilet Repair Visit Works

1. Call or book online

Pick a time. You get a 3-hour window and a text before the plumber arrives.

2. We check the whole toilet

We check the tank parts, the base, the flange, the supply line and the drain.

3. Fixed-rate price

You approve one price before any work is done.

4. Fixed and flushed

We flush it several times, check for leaks and clean up.

A standard toilet replacement usually takes about an hour or two.

Tell Us What's Going On. We'll Handle It.

Message and data rates may apply. Privacy Policy | Terms and Conditions

What Customers Say

★★★★★

“Jose replaced our toilet in the master bathroom. He called with his ETA when he was on the way, worked quickly and professionally. Install looks great. No complaints.”

Shaun L.
Google review

★★★★★

“Todd did an exceptional job explaining what could be done in place of repairing the toilet, as well as what it took to repair it. Because of his explanation, I decided to replace the toilet instead. Thank you Todd!”

Christina M.
Google review

★★★★★

“Step 1: Started my day with Daniel who did a great job assessing my toilet situation. I knew it was going to be either a repair or a replacement. Daniel assessed and within in hour we had a same day appointment to install an in-stock toilet. Awesome. Step 2: Another great solution and install from the Barnett Plumbing team. Jose helped install a new toilet for me and helped me understand what was going on with my toilet so I know what to expect for the future. True professional. Will definitely choose Barnett plumbing again in the future!”

Gita B.
Google review

Read more on our reviews page.

What Causes Toilet Problems

  • Worn tank parts. Flappers, fill valves and gaskets are rubber and plastic, and they wear out.
  • A failed wax ring. The seal under the toilet dries out or breaks when the toilet rocks.
  • Hard water. Minerals in Tri-Valley water build up in the tank and under the rim and weaken the flush.
  • A partial clog. A blockage in the toilet or the drain line causes slow flushes and repeat clogs.
  • A loose or damaged flange. When the flange fails, the toilet moves and the seal breaks.
New fill valve and flapper installed inside a toilet tank during a toilet repair

Toilet Care Tips

Flush only waste and toilet paper. Wipes cause clogs, even the ones labeled flushable. Skip drop-in tank tablets, which can wear out the rubber parts in the tank.

If the toilet runs, rocks or leaves water on the floor, have it fixed soon. A small leak at the base can rot the floor underneath. If the toilet gurgles or backs up along with other drains, the problem may be in the main line. See drain cleaning.

New toilet installed next to a glass shower in a bathroom with marble-look tile

Toilet Repair Across the Tri-Valley

We repair and replace toilets in each of these cities.

Common Questions

Should I repair my toilet or replace it?

Repair it if the problem is a worn part like a flapper or fill valve. Replace it if the porcelain is cracked, it clogs over and over, or the repairs keep adding up.

Most often a worn flapper that no longer seals, a fill valve that will not shut off, or a float set too high.

Yes. A running toilet can waste 200 gallons or more a day.

Usually a partial blockage in the drain line. If other drains are slow too, the main line may be the problem.

A standard replacement usually takes about an hour or two.

Yes. We take the old toilet away when we install the new one.

We offer same-day service across the Tri-Valley, with a 3-hour arrival window and a text when your plumber is on the way.

Usually a failed wax ring or a loose toilet. Have it fixed soon, because the water can damage the floor underneath.

Toilet Running, Leaking or Clogged? We Can Be There Today.

Call now or book online for a same-day visit.